Eileen Chang, Love in a Fallen City (1943)

I’m back, and just as I predicted, the books I finished before the holidays seem so so far away, as if I’d read them a century ago. What impression has this novela by Eileen Chang left me, then, a “century” later? A good one…

It’s incredible to see the difference of treatment between this tale of love and war (almost fairy tale, as it ends well despite the odds) and this other story “The tattered cloak“, almost on the same theme, written by Berberova the exact same year. Berberova’s tone was so gloomy and clearly depressed, while Chang still sees hope under the most dire circumstances: a stilted, repressive and hypocritical old Chinese family and the sudden onset of war in Hong Kong after Pearl Harbor attack.

The title almost says it all — at least, the story is as romantic as its title, but romantic with a surprisingly sour twist. Bai Liu-su is a divorced woman who has been taken back by her family in Shanghai in the early 1940s – at 28, she’s a disgrace who should hide away at “home” for the rest of her life, at the mercy of her female relatives’ scorn and her male relatives’ squandering habits (they got her money back as well, of course). She should certainly not, as she turns out to, outshine her younger cousins who are trying to get married. She unwillingly attracts rich and attractive Fan’s attention, and with the help of an unexpectedly friendly matchmaker, conspires to woe him.

But it’s not all Cinderella. Bai is deeply distrustful of men and marriage, and Fan has a strong reputation of a playboy. They find rather unconventional arrangements before truly falling in love. She must resist him for her fragile reputation’s sake, and yet if she resists him too much she will go back to the tediousness of her sad fate. But as she agrees to dance and spend an evening with him without chaperon, in her family’s eyes she has already compromised herself. So she doesn’t really have much of a choice when she travels to Hong Kong with the hope of seeing Fan again.

I had the wrong view (from Taiwanese friends where her works are very popular classics) that Eileen Chang’s stories were flowery romances. But instead, I discovered a rather dry view of male / female relations, bordering on cynicism. How interesting and refreshing! All too often, the pictures we get of old Shanghai are all greed, luxury and misery coexisting in crowded, dark opium dens. But I like the ideas that women living there had other aspirations and other options than just joining the Communists! Shanghai in this story is the dark side, the closed family circle, while Hong Kong represents the sunny side, nature and sea, with its expatriate community and its opening on Western ideas. A nice discovery!

Here’s Dorothy review of the short story collection. If you’ve reviewed this story, please let me know, I’ll link to your post as well!

2 thoughts on “Eileen Chang, Love in a Fallen City (1943)

  1. I enjoyed reading your comments about the book. I agree it’s not Cinderella. Personally, I think it’s better than Cinderella ’cause Liusu Bai has to work very hard to earn her love, it was not given to her just because of her appearance. The antagonist does not know what love is all about ’till all the hardship that she went through with Fan. But being Chang, she always end her stories with bitter, sad and realistic tones. There is no HAPPILY EVER AFTER! “Liuyuan even stopped teasing her, saving all his daring talk for other women. That was a good sign, worth celebrating, since it meant that she was his own– his wife in name and in truth. Still, it made her a little sad”. Bai got the title, the money in the end. Yet, she could not fully captured his heart.

  2. Pingback: Ye Zhaoyan, Nankin 1937 A Love Story (Chinese, 1996) « Smithereens

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.